Kesey IV: Debate Points (conclusion)
Pro/Con
Find a relevant passage and make prepare to make the case (5 min):
1. McMurphy’s ward-mates are justified in losing faith in him, seeing him as the self-serving instigator and con-man described by the nurse.
2. The decision to adminster shock therapy, unless he “admits he was wrong” is reasonable therapy (for the time).
3. McMurphy’s stubborn readiness to endure shock treatments shows he is trapped in his role as ward hero.
4. McMurphy’s final attack is justified and noble, despite being effectively a suicide act.
5. Chief’s smothering of McMurphy is a sacrifice benefiting the men, not an act of mercy.
HW:
Read first 15 pages of Sherman Alexie for a content quiz Friday.